When reading about teacher-controlled and student-controlled techniques, at first it seemed clear on which is best. But as I read onward, I began to feel that each technique can be useful in certain situations. In my opinion, I feel like a teacher-controlled, manipulative classroom would be best for younger students- in this case, a beginners English course. Although not completely black and white, this technique would work well in this senario because younger, or beginners students are not as advanced in the topic. With that said, only a little bit of teacher-student communication is need. On the contrary, student-controlled classrooms seem best in a more advanced setting because students are able to take what they know and channel it into the classroom to help each other and themselves.
Just in my own opinion, I personally like a student-controlled setting more because it is a great way to keep the atmosphere alive. Being a student my whole life, I tend to enjoy interactive classrooms more because it keeps me alert and amused when learning.
You said, "I began to feel that each technique can be useful in certain situations." I agree. The choice of technique depends on the age of the students, the ability level of the students, and their expected learning outcomes. We'll talk about this in class with regards to activity choices in grammar classes.
ReplyDelete